Listen to this man. Seven years of college, you know. Trying to reason with 2020 and, now, 2022.

Saturday, August 9, 2014

Who Sings It Better: Percy Sledge or R. Kelly

From WNCT, 1070 AM, Greenville North Carolina.

The station had its listeners watch two videos by the artists and vote on their favorite.  It was "When a Man Loves a Woman" by Percy Sledge.  R. Kelly did it from a woman's viewpoint and called it "When a Woman Loves."

I am not an R.Kelly fan at all, and, of course, anything 60s, especially soul music, has my vote.

I voted before seeing either video, and it was for Percy.

Percy Sledge recorded his song in 1966 in an Alabama studio and it hit #1 on both pop and R&B charts.  It is listed as one at #34 as one of the greatest songs of all-time by Rolling Stone Magazine.

R. Kelly's version was on his 2011 Love Letter album and is from a woman's point of view.

It would have been a great 1960s soul song, one that would have done STAX proud .  I doubt there has ever been a song with more soul.  R. kelly should make a whole album done in 60s style on reply songs from the 60s.

Both versions are incredible, but I wish i had seen the R. Kelly video before I voted as I would have had to think seriously before voting for Percy.

By the way, the voting on WNCT AM was 94.4% for Percy and 5.56% for R. Kelly.

When a Man Loves a Woman.  --Roaddog


SIGNS OF OLD AGE:  The end of your tie doesn't come anywhere near the top of your pants.



No comments: